Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Conclusion


We can learn so much by reflecting on impactful educators and applying their positive attributes and characteristics that to our practice.

Now



Currently, I teach art in the museum setting. The on the plus side I do not have to deal as much with discipline or grades, the exhibitions are constantly changing so I feel like I am always learning and it is great to teach with the original artwork. I miss the relationships that you form with students and seeing them progress over time.

I would describe my teaching method as the sponge approach. I try to take the best aspects of many approaches. Visual Thinking Strategies (VTS) has helped me to realize that I don’t need to be the expert. You can empower students by encouraging and validating their thoughts and opinions about a work of art. I incorporate visual culture as a way to connect art work to their lives and also to give students the skills they need to look critically at the images and messages they receive. It is also important to teach students the language of art. And also creating space for the students lives which reflects the influence of the anti-bias approach.

I believe you should challenge students and set high expectations for them. Just the other day I asked a group of young homeschool students record their best guess for the number of balloons the room was filled with (a work of art by Martin Creed). A mother interrupted me to tell me that she didn’t think the students could do that. She then asked her daughter who said that she could complete the task. The mother then said, “I stand corrected.” I believe students will rise to meet the challenges you set before them and will in turn gain confidence.

First Year


I was at a school with another art teacher and felt like the principal compared me a first year teacher to a veteran. I wish I would have known how to/that I needed to advocate and educate others what I was doing in my classroom. I was creating installations, incorporating visual culture, using technology to create art but the projects didn’t look as “polished” as my college so it was not as good. As a first year teacher I wished that I had had more tools/preparation for dealing with parents. (they terrify me) I felt isolated didn’t want to admit that I needed help with classroom management and keeping up with grading, techniques for including and adapting projects for special needs students.

Responses


These are the questions I asked: What field do you currently work in? Did you have a teacher that influenced your career path? Consider your favorite class or professor. What made that experience unique? Did you take art classes? Please describe your experience. Was it lecture based, interactive, studio based, copying works of “masters,” ect?

Ten responded that a teacher was influential in their career path and ten said that no teacher was influential in their career path.

Characteristics that made teachers stand out were: a passion for the subject, engaging students on a personal level and setting high expectations. The responses for unique experiences: “They went out of their way to facilitate students’ learning because it was their passion.” “My ICU professor was one [of] the first professor[s] that I felt actually taught us rather than just read from a powerpoint.” “The teacher got to know the students as individuals, rather than merely lecturing, keeping distance from the students and never knowing them as anything different than one of his many students.” “This professor was one of two that actually made me think.” “She was a high performer and had the same expectations of students professionally and academically.” “Took a personal interest in me (and not just in me, but in all the students) and really encouraged me as a person to grow in my abilities and knowledge.” “My favorite classes always had professors who were approachable, who seemed to understand (and care) what we were going through as students.”

Of the participants 17 of the 20 had taken an art class. Most stated that the class was a combination of lecture and interactive. “I am not an artistic or creative person, but I do have very fond memories of my art classes. Even though I was not a very good artist, I never felt like my teachers were judging me or thought that I shouldn't be in the class.” “It mostly consisted of watching the teacher demonstrate something, and then trying to mimic what she had just done. There was very little, if any, discussion of "masters" or styles associated with certain artists or time periods. It wasn't a negative experience in that I disliked it, but I feel like things could have been done differently so that I would have gotten more out of it. I'm not the most artistically talented person, but I think I could have developed a greater appreciation for art if I had been taught more about some of the masters or styles during certain time periods.” “My first experience with art class was very productive, we learned the fundamentals of drawings which proved to be beneficial later on.” “All very interactive, and I think that's what I liked about it. Even basic classes in college were very hands on. The only class I had a negative experience was a with a professor in college who insisted my pieces weren't saleable enough.”

These responses caused me to consider: Even if students do not pursue a career in the arts how can we encourage confidence in themselves as life long creators?

College


In college in our visual studies courses I learned the importance of incorporating visual culture, creating an anti-bias curriculum that invited students lives into the classroom, discussing contemporary artists and women artist. Some of the texts we used were: The Guerrilla Girls; Bedside Companion to the History of Western Art, From Our Voices Art Educators Speak Out About Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgendered Issues, Hollis Sigler’s Breast Cancer Journal and Anti-Bias Curriculum Tools for Empowering Young Children. In our course we had numerous opportunities to apply these concepts in a variety of environments: alternative school, head start school, school where there was not art teacher and in our student teaching placement.

On to the next one

In high school there was only one art teacher and he treated girls differently than boys. I took ceramics, photography and art one and two from him. After I turned in a self-portrait he asked me if it was a portrait of my sister? I was devastated after working diligently on the project and to be insulted as I turned in my assignment. Obviously it was not a drawing of my sister if the assignment was to draw myself. I despised the way I felt in his classroom and was determined to find a better approach.

Growing up my art teachers were never my favorite. In fourth grade it was Ms. Reed. She made cotton candy for the class on one special occasion and during recess she would let me stay inside and hang posters for her or do other odd jobs. She was kind, she made learning fun and she was real. Ms. Reed’s father passed away. And I remember she played “Bye-Bye Miss American Pie” because the song reminded her of her dad and she wanted to share that with us. To this day when I hear that song it reminds me of her father.

Ready to Start

First, here is my story. In elementary school I had a three different teachers. I don’t remember anything specifically about art class just three projects that I really enjoyed. Going outside to paint from observation, a magazine project where we cut the page in half competed the other portion of the face (I enjoyed the challenge of drawing realistically) and working together to creating a papier-mâché pumpkin patch that was on display for the school.

In middle school my art teachers name was Mrs. Whoolheater. She was an elderly woman who used an electric scooter. I remember being terrified of her. She would always say if we left our feet in her path she would run over them. We would sit quietly at our tables and work on our assignments.

In junior high each assignment was distributed on a project sheet. We were then expected to sit silently and work in our sketchbooks. A privilege given in this class was the opportunity to choose the radio station for the period.

Introduction



While reflecting on my personal history and how teachers influenced my career path I was interested in discovering if others had similar experiences. I asked friends, family members and co-workers to respond to five questions. I received twenty responses.