Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Responses


These are the questions I asked: What field do you currently work in? Did you have a teacher that influenced your career path? Consider your favorite class or professor. What made that experience unique? Did you take art classes? Please describe your experience. Was it lecture based, interactive, studio based, copying works of “masters,” ect?

Ten responded that a teacher was influential in their career path and ten said that no teacher was influential in their career path.

Characteristics that made teachers stand out were: a passion for the subject, engaging students on a personal level and setting high expectations. The responses for unique experiences: “They went out of their way to facilitate students’ learning because it was their passion.” “My ICU professor was one [of] the first professor[s] that I felt actually taught us rather than just read from a powerpoint.” “The teacher got to know the students as individuals, rather than merely lecturing, keeping distance from the students and never knowing them as anything different than one of his many students.” “This professor was one of two that actually made me think.” “She was a high performer and had the same expectations of students professionally and academically.” “Took a personal interest in me (and not just in me, but in all the students) and really encouraged me as a person to grow in my abilities and knowledge.” “My favorite classes always had professors who were approachable, who seemed to understand (and care) what we were going through as students.”

Of the participants 17 of the 20 had taken an art class. Most stated that the class was a combination of lecture and interactive. “I am not an artistic or creative person, but I do have very fond memories of my art classes. Even though I was not a very good artist, I never felt like my teachers were judging me or thought that I shouldn't be in the class.” “It mostly consisted of watching the teacher demonstrate something, and then trying to mimic what she had just done. There was very little, if any, discussion of "masters" or styles associated with certain artists or time periods. It wasn't a negative experience in that I disliked it, but I feel like things could have been done differently so that I would have gotten more out of it. I'm not the most artistically talented person, but I think I could have developed a greater appreciation for art if I had been taught more about some of the masters or styles during certain time periods.” “My first experience with art class was very productive, we learned the fundamentals of drawings which proved to be beneficial later on.” “All very interactive, and I think that's what I liked about it. Even basic classes in college were very hands on. The only class I had a negative experience was a with a professor in college who insisted my pieces weren't saleable enough.”

These responses caused me to consider: Even if students do not pursue a career in the arts how can we encourage confidence in themselves as life long creators?

No comments:

Post a Comment